DIY or Hire a Web Designer? How to Choose the Right Path for Your Small Business

Thinking about getting your business online but not sure whether to do it yourself or hand it over to someone else?

It's one of the most common questions I get — and the honest answer is: it depends. Not on what's trendy, or what your neighbour did, but on your time, your budget, and how central your website is to actually winning work.

This post walks through both paths honestly, so you can make the call that's right for your business — not someone else's.

The DIY Route — When It Makes Sense

Wix Studio gives you genuine power as a DIYer. Drag-and-drop layout, built-in mobile responsiveness, no code required. If you have time, a bit of patience, and some instinct for what looks clean, you can build something functional yourself.

DIY tends to work well when:

• You're just starting out and need something simple online fast

• Your budget is tight and a basic presence is enough for now

• You enjoy learning new tools and don't mind trial and error

• Your website is more of a "confirmation" for people who already know you, rather than your main source of new leads

The real cost of DIY isn't money — it's time. Most small business owners underestimate how long it takes to build even a simple site from scratch: choosing a template, writing your own copy, figuring out mobile layout, connecting your domain. For many people, that's 20–40 hours they didn't budget for.

Before you go DIY, ask yourself honestly:

• Do I have 20–40 hours available in the next few weeks to build and refine this?

• Am I comfortable writing my own copy and sourcing images?

• Is my website a nice-to-have, or do I need it to actively bring in enquiries?

If you do go down the DIY path, start with a minimal Wix Studio template rather than one of the heavily designed ones — they're easier to make your own. I've written a practical guide on how to Use Wix Studio Templates Without Your Site Looking Generic →

The Professional Route — When It's Worth It

Hiring a web designer isn't just about getting a prettier website. It's about getting a website that's structured to convert visitors into enquiries — with the right copy, the right layout, and the right SEO foundations in place from day one.

A professionally built site tends to be worth the investment when:

• Your website is how new customers find and evaluate you

• You want to show up in Google search results for your area or service

• You don't have the time (or the desire) to learn a design platform

• You want it done properly once, rather than rebuilt in 12 months when the DIY version isn't working

• 
  

The other thing most people don't factor in: your time has value. If you're a tradie billing out at $80/hr, spending 30 hours building your own website is effectively a $2,400 job — and you might still end up with something that doesn't convert. A professional build at a similar cost gets you a strategic result without you disappearing from your actual work for a month.

What Does It Actually Cost to Hire Someone?

This is usually where the conversation gets vague. It doesn't have to be.

At Digital Manifest, there are three straightforward options:

Starter Site — from $550 A single-page scroll site with a contact form. Built on a pre-defined structure so it's fast to deliver. Best for sole traders who need something live and professional quickly.

Growth Website — from $2,200 Four pages (Home, About, Services, Contact), custom design, professional copywriting, SEO foundations, and Google Business Profile setup or optimisation included. This is the most popular option for local service businesses.

Complete Build — custom pricing For businesses with more complex needs: think 6+ pages, booking systems, service area pages, blog setup, or ongoing content and SEO support.

See the full pricing breakdown →

What About a Middle Path?

One of the best things about Wix Studio is that it makes collaboration genuinely easy. You can hire a designer to build the site, then manage updates yourself afterward — no ongoing retainer required, no needing to call someone every time you change your hours.

Think of it like getting a builder in for the structure, then moving the furniture around yourself once they're done.

This is actually how most of my clients work. I build the site, hand it over with a training session, and they're confident managing day-to-day updates on their own.

A Quick Side-by-Side

Feature	DIY	Hire a Pro
Upfront cost	Your hourly rate	From $550
Time investment	High (20-40+ hours)	Low
Design quality	Depends on your eye	Consistent, professional
SEO foundations	Easy to miss	Built in from the start
Copywriting	Your write it	Included
Stress levels	Potentially High	Low
Post-launch updates	All you	Your choice

So Which One Is Right for You?

If budget is the primary constraint and you have time to invest, DIY is a legitimate starting point. A basic Wix site done well beats no site at all.

If your website needs to work — to show up in Google, to convince someone who doesn't know you yet, to look as professional as your service actually is — then a professional build is almost always the better investment.

And if you're not sure? A free 15-minute call usually clears it up fast. We'll look at where your business is, what you actually need, and I'll tell you honestly if something simpler would do the job.

Book a free 15-minute call →

TL;DR

• DIY is great if you’ve got time, patience, and some design instincts

• Hiring a pro means you’ll get a strategic, polished result — without any late-night headaches

• Wix Studio makes it easy to collaborate: get a pro build, but manage it yourself afterward

• There’s no one-size-fits-all answer — it depends on your needs and bandwidth

While you're here

I've been doing a deep-dive into how local businesses across Wollondilly actually show up online — and the results were more interesting than I expected. If you want to know where the gaps are (and whether your business has them), start here:

I checked 50 Wollondilly businesses. Here's what I found →

Got questions?

📩 Drop a comment below or shoot me an email; let's chat!